PyWeek - The Sea of Good and Bad - feedback

Fun	Prod	Inno	Comments
2	5	4	Quite a nice idea but I lost interest fairly quickly. + a billion points for voice acting
4	4	4	-
4	5	4	Love the goofy awful soap script and then came the voice acting. First game I was laughing out loud to. My wife is concerned. I'm adding voices to my next game for sure! Sound and graphics are great and there's even replayablity.
5	5	5	Looks great, the story is great, the controls are fun and the action is tight. I especially like the modeling on the boats and monsters. Really good job, keep up the good work! I do kind of wish you had converted the wavs to oggs or something. Call me old fashioned, but 46MB for voice samples is kind of a lot!
4	5	3	This game manages to accomplish an enjoyable and tense experience even if it is aggravatingly difficult. The voice acting is actually very effective in giving the game depth to compensate for its lack of complexity. And this simple mechanic creates an easy to learn game even if it is a little unbalanced.
3	4	4	wow -impressive work
3	4	4	Interesting mechanic, and the cut-scenes are really cute. The actual gameplay ends up feeling a bit bland, though.
3	5	5	good graphic, good music, good characters, innovative gameplay but (in my opinion) a little bit boring, sorry.
4	4	4	Nice story, and an interesting game mechanic. I was expecting more opportunities to make perfect shapes, but the distribution of points just seems to be random.
1	4	4	Great effort on dubbing all of the sounds, the game felt like work though. It was fun for the first two shapes.
3	5	3	great graphics and music. I found the game a bit frustrating though!
3	5	4	Congratulations! What a lovely game!
3	3	4	The storyline confused me, and collecting the mana shapes seemed a bit irrelevant.
3	5	3	1) Put files in a folder! 2) Am I really supposed to get 1 million? 3) Amazing dialogs and drawings
3	4	4	Interesting gameplay mechanics, but it isn't really replayable.
3	4	2	Voice acting added a nice touch to the game.